Sebastian Giovinco, Jozy Altidore - Toronto FC - Fantasy

MLS Fantasy: Ranking the top 50 players for September

Reid and Mike are joined by special Patreon guest Winston Mesmer to review the top fantasy points from Round 26 and preview all of the games from Round 27. Mike also goes over the remaining international call-ups who still have games and talks about the potential impact on their Round 27 availability. We also answer the question on if you should bring David Villa into your team this week. Tune in for that and more!


Time is running out fast in the MLS Fantasy season. We’ve got only seven weeks left in the 2017 campaign, meaning you’ve only got seven chances to catch a rival, achieve a new high score or reach the top of your head-to-head league.

To maximize your results, you’ll have to plan for some inevitable bumps in the road. There are plenty of potential pitfalls, and plenty of midweek games. Every remaining round in September is a double game week, so be sure to get your transfers in early and keep an eye out for potential squad rotation. There will be plenty of opportunities for major points this month – make sure you take full advantage.

Below is my updated list of the top 50 MLS Fantasy players for September. This list does not focus on just the upcoming Fantasy round, but tries to consider how desirable players may be to managers over the entire month.

Rank Player Position Team Price ($)
1 David Villa FWD NYC 12.3
2 Sebastian Giovinco FWD TOR 13.5
3 Miguel Almiron MID ATL 10.0
4 Maxi Moralez MID NYC 9.5
5 Victor Vazquez MID TOR 9.5
6 Lee Nguyen MID NE 11.0
7 Diego Valeri MID POR 11.6
8 Ignacio Piatti MID MTL 11.7
9 Nicolas Lodeiro MID SEA 11.9
10 Jozy Altidore FWD TOR 10.3
11 Sacha Kljestan MID NY 11.6
12 Blerim Dzemaili MID MTL 9.2
13 Josef Martinez FWD ATL 9.5
14 Romain Alessandrini MID LA 10.6
15 Albert Rusnak MID RSL 10.0
16 Ethan Finlay MID MIN 8.5
17 Bradley Wright-Phillips FWD NY 10.6
18 Benny Feilhaber MID SKC 10.8
19 Erick "Cubo" Torres FWD HOU 8.7
20 Luis Silva MID RSL 7.3
21 Yamil Asad MID ATL 8.4
22 Bastian Schweinsteiger MID CHI 9.0
23 Haris Medunjanin MID PHI 8.6
24 Dax McCarty MID CHI 9.5
25 Michael Bradley MID TOR 9.1
26 Cristian Roldan MID SEA 8.0
27 Anibal Godoy MID SJ 7.0
28 Samuel Piette MID MTL 6.5
29 Alex Ring MID NYC 7.7
30 Ibson MID MIN 6.9
31 Justin Meram MID CLB 10.0
32 Kei Kamara FWD NE 9.8
33 Clint Dempsey FWD SEA 10.1
34 Nemanja Nikolic FWD CHI 10.2
35 Chris Wondolowski FWD SJ 8.4
36 Ola Kamara FWD CLB 10.6
37 CJ Sapong FWD PHI 8.2
38 Teal Bunbury MID NE 7.0
39 Kevin Molino MID MIN 10.2
40 Cyle Larin FWD ORL 9.2
41 Leandro Gonzalez Pirez DEF ATL 6.5
42 Chad Marshall DEF SEA 6.8
43 Ike Opara DEF SKC 6.5
44 Justin Morrow DEF TOR 7.1
45 Antonio Delamea DEF NE 6.3
46 Jonathan Mensah DEF CLB 6.0
47 Adolfo Machado DEF HOU 5.2
48 Alexander Callens DEF NYC 5.2
49 Kofi Opare DEF DC 4.7
50 Brad Guzan GK ATL 6.1

Must-Own Players (1-7)

I don’t like to use the term “must-own” often, but these players all fit the bill. They are clear targets when playing at home and can often be relied upon to generate solid points when on the road. Until this month, no team had more than one player in this category, but with the continued success of Toronto FC and NYCFC, it makes a lot of fantasy sense to double up on their key attackers. This is why Maxi Moralez and Victor Vazquez join David Villa and Sebastian Giovinco as “must-own” players. The only notable loss is Nemanja Nikolic, who dropped off the list due to his concerning rough patch.

The Short List (8-20)

These are the players who can usually be relied upon to score a goal or earn an assist in most home games, but are not always as consistent on the road. There are several new names in this section including Ignacio Piatti, who continues to be a driving force for Montreal. Also of note is Ethan Finlay, who is becoming a key playmaker for Minnesota, and finally-healthy striker Josef Martinez ahead of Atlanta’s huge run of DGWs.

Frequent Point Producers (21-30)

This section is a mashup of players with high floors and high ceilings who can usually be relied upon for 4-5 points a round. With the previously mention DGW run that Atlanta will soon start, Yamil Asad is at the top of this section. The rest of the names have stayed the same, except for Montreal’s new defensive mid Samuel Piette. He replaced Albert Rusnak, who recently moved into the top 20.

Hit or Miss (31-40)

Many of these players are just starting to get back in form (Justin Meram), are on a hot streak (Teal Bunbury), or are a bright spot on a struggling team (CJ Sapong). This is the most difficult range to place players. They’re usually not all that reliable, but do have flashes of greatness. They could be worth a shot during a favorable matchup or if you want a differential play.

Premium Defenders

It’s hard for a defender to make it far up my top 50 list, but several always manage to climb the ranks. Don’t overlook Columbus newcomer Jonathan Mensah, who has overcome a tough start to his MLS career and has put up plenty of big point totals recently. D.C. United are on a bit of a heater, and Kofi Opare could be a player to help grab some unexpected clean sheets. And don’t forget about the goalkeepers, with Brad Guzan potentially set for some great scores thanks to Atlanta’s upcoming DGWs.

Are there any other players who you would add to this list? If you make a well-reasoned case for an addition, adjustment, or removal of a player in the comments, I’ll take a look and consider it for the future.

Stay connected: To get all the latest Fantasy news and advice, download the MLS app and sign up for MLS Fantasy notifications. To sign up for notifications, select the main menu, choose settings. Within the settings menu, select News & Videos notifications and turn on notifications for "Fantasy Soccer."

Topics: 

Stay connected: The official MLS app keeps you connected with the latest news, highlights, scores, standings, and analysis all for FREE. Download for iOS (Apple) or Download for Android