• First MLS goal - vs. Los Angeles Galaxy, 4/25/2021 in the 26th minute, assisted by Brian White
• First MLS assist - vs. New York City FC, 8/17/2019 (with FC Cincinnati)
• First MLS game - at Columbus Crew, 8/10/2019 (with FC Cincinnati)
• First MLS start - at Columbus Crew, 8/10/2019 (with FC Cincinnati)
2021: Set career-highs in games played (22), games started (19), minutes played (1,837), goals (2), and assists (2) in his first season with New York...scored first career MLS goal against Los Angeles Galaxy on April 25... tallied his first assist for the club on August 18 against Columbus Crew... recorded his first career MLS game-winning goal on October 2 against FC Cincinnati. Playoffs: Made his MLS Cup Playoffs debut against Philadelphia Union on Nov. 20... started and played all 120 minutes.
2020 (FC Cincinnati): Set career-high in games played (21), games started (15), and minutes played (1,441)...made his first start of the season against Atlanta United on July 16 in MLS is Back tournament...started in six of the seven shoutouts earned.
2019 (FC Cincinnati/Charlotte Independence): MLS: Started in five of eight appearances...totaled 482 minutes played...recorded first MLS appearance and start against Columbus Crew on August 10... tallied first MLS assist against New York City FC on August 17. USL: Appeared and started in 14 matches...recorded 1,260 minutes played...scored three goals and added one assist...made professional debut and scored first professional goal against Indy Eleven on March 15... tallied his first professional assist against NYRB II on April 13.
Started all 90 matches he appeared in for Indiana University...Gutman won the 2018 Herman Trophy...recorded 11 goals and nine assists in 23 matches played during his senior year... led Hoosiers to a semifinal appearance in 2018 NCAA Tournament and a National Championship in 2017...tallied 20 goals and 17 assists over his four-year career.
New York Red Bulls loan Andrew Gutman for one year from Atlanta United on March 9, 2021.