New England Revolution goalkeeper Matt Turner was the hero in the end, making two saves across the five Liga MX All-Star penalties he saw, with another flying off-target. Orlando City superstar Nani had a chance to win it from the spot but miscued his effort into the stands before Pepi took the final shot, which found the back of the net after clipping the crossbar.
It was an eventful and intense 90 minutes plus the shootout, with a sold-out Banc of California Stadium in full voice as the rival leagues put on a spectacle in the city of stars.
The Liga MX All-Stars took the lead in the 20th minute through Cruz Azul forward Jonathan Rodriguez. Rodriguez was on the receiving end of an inch-perfect cross from right back Jorge Sanchez, taking an exquisite first touch off his chest before half-volleying a shot into the bottom corner.
Jesus Murillo equalized for the MLS All-Stars in the 53rd minute, as the LAFC center back scored at his home stadium in front of the 3252 Supporters' Section packed with delighted fans. Murillo's towering header gave Pumas goalkeeper Alfredo Talavera no chance at the near post.
Pepi was lively after coming on in the second half and had multiple attempts at searching for the game-winner, though couldn't find the scoresheet until his crowning moment in the shootout.
The first on-field fireworks arrived in the ninth minute when Sanchez made an acrobatic overhead goal-line clearance to save a certain goal for MLS. LAFC's Diego Rossi got clean-through on goal and chipped Memo Ochoa, only for the Club America defender to come flying in to deny him.
All six Seattle Sounders All-Star selections started the match together, including Alex and Cristian Roldan, who became the first brothers in MLS All-Star history to play alongside one another. The first subs came in the 27th minute. The MLS All-Stars used 27 players, while the Liga MX All-Stars called on 26.
- THE BIG PICTURE: It was a historic evening around these parts, the first iteration of the MLS All-Star Game featuring the Liga MX All-Stars. The on-field product was a success, with players going full tilt and putting on a show for the raucous crowd on a warm Los Angeles summer night. Beyond the final score or the micro to come from the match itself, that'll be the legacy.
- MOMENT OF THE MATCH: It has to be the winning penalty, right? And of course it was Pepi, the man of the moment as both the United States and Mexico national teams hope to call up the dual-national for World Cup Qualifying. The starboy stepped up and took the responsibility in stride.
- MVP PRESENTED BY TARGET: While Jorge Sanchez produced two huge moments that defined the first half, Matt Turner was the penalty shootout's hero. He denied Rogelio Funes Mori and Salvador Reyes from 12 yards out.