2021: Matt Turner (New England Revolution)
FINALISTS:
- Andre Blake (Philadelphia Union)
- Maxime Crepeau (Vancouver Whitecaps FC)
- Matt Turner (New England Revolution)
- Joe Willis (Nashville SC)
- William Yarbrough (Colorado Rapids)
2020 Andre Blake (Philadelphia Union)
FINALISTS:
- Andre Blake (Philadelphia Union)
- Eloy Room (Columbus Crew SC)
- Matt Turner (New England Revolution)
2019: Vito Mannone (Minnesota United FC)
FINALISTS:
- Bill Hamid (D.C. United)
- Sean Johnson (New York City FC)
- Vito Mannone (Minnesota United FC)
2018: Zack Steffen (Columbus Crew SC)
FINALISTS:
- Stefan Frei (Seattle Sounders FC)
- Luis Robles (New York Red Bulls)
- Zack Steffen (Columbus Crew SC)
2017: Tim Melia (Sporting Kansas City)
FINALISTS:
- Andre Blake (Philadelphia Union)
- Stefan Frei (Seattle Sounders FC)
- Tim Melia (Sporting Kansas City)
2016: Andre Blake (Philadelphia Union)
FINALISTS:
- Andre Blake (Philadelphia Union)
- Tim Howard (Colorado Rapids)
- Luis Robles (New York Red Bulls)
2015: Luis Robles (New York Red Bulls)
FINALISTS:
- Bill Hamid (D.C. United)
- David Ousted (Vancouver Whitecaps FC)
- Luis Robles (New York Red Bulls)
2014: Bill Hamid (D.C. United)
FINALISTS:
- Steve Clark (Columbus Crew)
- Bill Hamid (D.C. United)
- Nick Rimando (Real Salt Lake)
2013: Donovan Ricketts (Portland Timbers)
FINALISTS:
- Jimmy Nielsen (Sporting Kansas City)
- Nick Rimando (Real Salt Lake)
- Donovan Ricketts (Portland Timbers)
2012: Jimmy Nielsen (Sporting Kansas City)
FINALISTS:
- Michael Gspurning (Seattle Sounders FC)
- Dan Kennedy (Chivas USA)
- Jimmy Nielsen (Sporting Kansas City)
2011: Kasey Keller (Seattle Sounders FC)
FINALISTS:
- Kevin Hartman (FC Dallas)
- Kasey Keller (Seattle Sounders FC)
- Faryd Mondragon (Philadelphia Union)
2010: Donovan Ricketts (LA Galaxy)
FINALISTS:
- Kevin Hartman (FC Dallas)
- Donovan Ricketts (LA Galaxy)
- Nick Rimando (Real Salt Lake)
2009: Zach Thornton (Chivas USA)
FINALISTS:
- Kasey Keller (Seattle Sounders FC)
- Donovan Ricketts (Los Angeles Galaxy)
- Zach Thornton (Chivas USA)
2008: Jon Busch (Chicago Fire)
FINALISTS:
- Jon Busch (Chicago Fire)
- William Hesmer (Columbus Crew)
- Matt Reis (New England Revolution)
2007: Brad Guzan (Chivas USA)
FINALISTS:
- Brad Guzan (Chivas USA)
- Pat Onstad (Houston Dynamo)
- Matt Reis (New England Revolution)
2006: Troy Perkins (D.C. United)
FINALISTS:
- Joe Cannon (Colorado Rapids)
- Troy Perkins (D.C. United)
- Matt Reis (New England Revolution)
2005: Pat Onstad (San Jose Earthquakes)
FINALISTS:
- Joe Cannon (Colorado Rapids)
- Pat Onstad (San Jose Earthquakes)
- Matt Reis (New England Revolution)
2004: Joe Cannon (Colorado Rapids)
FINALISTS:
- Jon Busch (Columbus Crew)
- Joe Cannon (Colorado Rapids)
- Kevin Hartman (Los Angeles Galaxy)
2003: Pat Onstad (San Jose Earthquakes)
FINALISTS:
- Pat Onstad (San Jose Earthquakes)
- Zach Thornton (Chicago Fire)
- Kevin Hartman (Los Angeles Galaxy)
2002: Joe Cannon (San Jose Earthquakes)
FINALISTS:
- Joe Cannon (San Jose Earthquakes)
- Tim Howard (MetroStars)
- Nick Rimando (D.C. United)
2001: Tim Howard (MetroStars)
FINALISTS:
- Joe Cannon (San Jose Earthquakes)
- Tim Howard (MetroStars)
- Zach Thornton (Chicago Fire)
2000: Tony Meola (Kansas City Wizards)
FINALISTS:
- Scott Garlick (Tampa Bay Mutiny)
- Kevin Hartman (Los Angeles Galaxy)
- Tony Meola (Kansas City Wizards)
1999: Kevin Hartman (Los Angeles Galaxy)
FINALISTS:
- Kevin Hartman (Los Angeles Galaxy)
- Matt Jordan (Dallas Burn)
- Scott Garlick (Tampa Bay Mutiny)
1998: Zach Thornton (Chicago Fire)
TOP THREE IN VOTING:
- Tony Meola (MetroStars)
- Mark Dodd (Dallas Burn)
- Zach Thornton (Chicago Fire)
1997: Brad Friedel (Columbus Crew)
TOP THREE IN VOTING:
- Mark Dodd (Dallas Burn)
- Brad Friedel (Columbus Crew)
- Walter Zenga (New England Revolution)
1996: Mark Dodd (Dallas Burn)
FINALISTS:
- Mark Dodd (Dallas Burn)
- Brad Friedel (Columbus Crew)
- Tony Meola (MetroStars)
