2026 MLS Cup Playoffs

Columbus Crew: Can they upset Inter Miami & Lionel Messi?

26MLS_Playoffs_Mendez-CLB

Back in 2023, the Columbus Crew rode the adrenaline boost of a marquee Designated Player summer signing to an MLS Cup presented by Audi title under their new head coach.

Three years later, the Crew (No. 7) hope to accomplish the same as they begin their Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs journey against Lionel Messi and defending champions Inter Miami CF (No. 2), starting with Saturday's Eastern Conference Round One Best-of-3 Series opener at Nu Stadium (6 pm ET | Apple TV).

“To be honest, you never want to play against one of the best in the world who can change a game on its head,” Crew goalkeeper Patrick Schulte told MLSsoccer.com. “But I think for us, it wasn't even the matchup of who we were going to play. It was more, let's be grateful that we're going to get the opportunity to play in the playoffs. We could have easily been playing in the [Wild Card] game.

“I think we're just more grateful that we're in the Best-of-3 round already and we don't have to worry about that extra game. You're going to have to play anyone at any point if you want to be lifting the trophy on December 18th. So I think that's been our motto: we're obviously going to have to play who we play. No matter who it is, we just gotta embrace it.”

Massive test

Homegrown midfielder Taha Habroune can certainly be counted among the Crew players embracing the challenge, recently going viral on social media for his excited on-field reaction to learning Columbus' Round One opponent.

Regardless of mindset, there’s no hiding that facing the 2025 MLS Cup champions – led by their iconic No. 10 – carries extra weight.

“It's someone I've grown up watching and admired from a young age, and now being able to play against him, it's different than an MLS game,” said Crew captain Sean Zawadzki.

“It's playoffs. It's the knockout round. And he always has even more. He always finds that extra level up.”

Schulte is well familiar with the Argentine, delivering a clutch tip save on Messi in the Crew’s 2-1 win over Inter Miami in September, shortly after being beaten by the eight-time Ballon d’Or winner with a stunning free kick.

“Be on your toes 24/7 and be ready for anything,” Schulte advised about facing the two-time Golden Boot presented by Audi winner and potentially three-time Landon Donovan MLS MVP.

“He's got me before, and I would love to say that he's never going to get me again, but it's the way football goes. He's going to get an opportunity, and he's going to take advantage of it. He only needs one."

Despite Messi’s best efforts, Columbus went unbeaten against Miami this season (1W-0L-1D) and memorably ousted them en route to their 2024 Leagues Cup title.

Nevertheless, the Crew have no problem occupying the underdog role this time around.

“Miami [are] obviously the favorite against us. But they have to find a way to beat us twice,” said Zawadzki. “I think we have the mentality that we're going to go out there and, 'Ok, they can beat us, but we're not going to let it happen twice.' We’re going to do everything we can to prevent that from happening twice.”

Proof of concept

Columbus aren’t without precedent, either. Just look back at 2024, when Atlanta United, the No. 9 seed advancing from the Wild Card match, pulled off an unlikely Round One upset over then-record-setting Supporters' Shield champions Miami.

Better yet, ask Apple TV analyst Dax McCarty, one of the key cogs of that historic Atlanta coup. 

“Columbus will definitely be the slight underdog in this series… Lionel Messi is always going to be a slight favorite to win any series that he’s in because of his quality,” admitted McCarty. “But I know from experience that being an underdog against Inter Miami, while it can be a daunting task, they’re not infallible. And this Columbus team is significantly better all around than my 2024 Atlanta United team.”

“I’m grateful he thinks that,” said Atlanta legend and current Crew striker Josef Martínez, who remembers that series well.

“I think when you finish first in the table, you have to rest more … When you don't play for a long time, you lose a little bit of timing, so that's why I think on that day in ‘24 they lost against Atlanta, because they had to wait too much,” analyzed Martínez.

“In this case, it's not the same, but we have to go to win. It's a different time because it's playoffs. Playoffs is totally different. You can be the best team in the world, but in the next game, you go out. This is the beauty of this game.”

The DP difference

The other reason Columbus should be confident in their chances of dethroning the champs? Designated Players Brais Méndez (6g/4a) and Santiago Rodríguez (3g/8a), who joined this summer as the Crew shuffled their roster and brought quality in the final third.

Add in an early-season managerial switch where the club parted ways with Henrik Rydström in favor of interim Laurent Courtois, and Columbus encountered plenty of adversity to start 2026.

But once the Crew bonded under Courtois, charting a US Open Cup final run along the way, their DP newcomers and striker Gonzalo Tapia proved to be missing pieces. Quickly, Columbus went from slim playoff hopes to winning eight of their last nine matches and entering the playoffs as the hottest team in the league.

“Obviously, [they have a] tremendous amount of quality. The quality that you see week-in and week-out on the pitch,” Schulte noted about Méndez and Rodríguez. “But then I think just their experience, Santi's knowledge of the league and then Brais’s experience in LaLiga.

“Then just honestly, they're two tremendous guys. They're very personable, very no-ego, and they're just easy to connect with off the pitch. Then you get on the pitch and it carries over. One, as a human being and their work rate. But then two, their quality, which I think fits right into the DNA of this team.”

Déjà vu

If anyone knows what it takes to win MLS Cup, it’s someone who's been there before. And for Schulte, 2026 carries a familiar feeling.

“Similarity is the journey, with having a new coach coming in and cooking at the right time. That 2023 year we went through an identity change. We were learning under Wilfried (Nancy),” the USMNT goalkeeper said.

“Yeah, we were in a better spot all year in the standings, but we had our bumps and hit our roadblocks at many different points throughout that year. Towards the end of the year, we took off and really started to click. I think that's something very similar here, but I think also, obviously, having quality and guys that are all bought in is very similar.”

The resemblance doesn't stop there, as Columbus also had to prove road warriors in 2023, eliminating Orlando City in the Conference Semifinals and FC Cincinnati in the Conference Final before ultimately defeating LAFC for their third MLS Cup.

Now, the Crew would love nothing more than to bring more silverware to Ohio's capital city.

“In ‘23, we were the three-seed, and we still had to find a way. Obviously, the first round we had the advantage against Atlanta, playing two at home, but after that it was on the road. It's the same thing this year,” noted Zawadzki. 

“... But going on the road, we carry not only for ourselves as players in this club – it's also for the city. We're representing not only this club, but all the fans that can't make a trip to Miami. We're going to have to do it time and time again, no matter what round it is, no matter who we're playing, but to put our head down and represent everyone in Columbus because we can't be at home.”