Do MLS players have a problem scoring penalties in 2019?

Brad Guzan saves penalty - Atlanta United Columbus Crew

Late in NYCFC's 1-0 win over the Chicago Fire,Maxi Moralez stepped up for a penalty to seal the game. The Argentine struck his penalty well and put it on frame, but Fire 'keeper David Ousted was up to the challenge. 


It's the latest continuation of a surprising trend early in 2019: Penalties are being scored at their lowest rate since at least 2010, by no small margin. 


Since 2012, the league's penalty success rate has hovered between 76-79%, with the sample size as low as 72 penalties taken and as many as 138 attempts. This year, however, the shooters are not off to a great start, converting 70% of their spot kicks.


All stats per Opta:

Season
PKs scored
PKs taken
PK %
2010
48
56
85.71%
2011
69
84
82.14%
2012
57
72
79.17%
2013
63
81
77.78%
2014
103
134
76.87%
2015
84
108
77.78%
2016
84
109
77.06%
2017
91
119
76.47%
2018
109
138
78.99%
2019
31
44
70.45%

Traditionally, penalties are converted at around a 75% clip worldwide


It's early on, with more than enough time to right the ship, but interesting nonetheless. Maybe a few more penalties from Josef Martinez will bring that rate right back up.