Tuiloma peeled from the back post towards the top of the 18-yard box on a corner kick served by Diego Valeri, and with his body momentum steering him away from goal, swiveled his hips to unleash a full volley into the side netting.
It was a runaway victory for Tuiloma, as the New Zealand international won 75% of the vote. Another defender, the New York Red Bulls' Connor Lade, finished second with 10%. Tomas Martinez (6%), Shea Salinas (5%) and Wayne Rooney (4%) rounded out the ballot.
See all five nominated goals and the full breakdown of voting results in Week 9.