It's the talking point after every trade in any sport: Who got the better deal?
Numbers don't lie, and although they are certainly not exempt from an open interpretation, the data speak for themselves. And regarding the goalkeeper swap of Donovan Ricketts and Troy Perkins between Montreal and Portland, the results are fairly persuasive.
Montreal found a winner in Perkins.
Ahead in almost every category, the newly acquired Impact netminder has a higher catch success rate, fewer drops and more saves parried away to safety to name a few.
Yes, there are certainly some intangibles that are overlooked (e.g. Ricketts 90-plus international caps), but Montreal clearly appear to have gotten an upgrade. Timbers GM and interim head coach Gavin WIlkinson believes that the Timbers received an upgrade as well.
What do you think? Who got the better deal: Montreal or Portland? Let us know in the comment section below.
<b>Perkins</b> |
<b>Player Surname</b> |
<b>Ricketts</b> |
<p class="p2">35</p> |
<b>Goals Conceded</b> |
<p class="p2">39</p> |
<p class="p2">27</p> |
<b>Goals Conceded Inside Box</b> |
<p class="p2">33</p> |
<p class="p2">8</p> |
<b>Goals Conceded Outside Box</b> |
<p class="p2">6</p> |
<p class="p2">66</p> |
<b>Saves Made</b> |
<p class="p2">61</p> |
<p class="p2">31</p> |
<b>Saves Made from Inside Box</b> |
<p class="p2">32</p> |
<p class="p2">35</p> |
<b>Saves Made from Outside Box</b> |
<p class="p2">29</p> |
<p class="p3">65.35%</p> |
<b>Saves to Shots Ratio</b> |
<p class="p3">61.00%</p> |
<p class="p3">53.45%</p> |
<b>Saves to Shots ratio Inside Box</b> |
<p class="p3">49.23%</p> |
<p class="p3">81.40%</p> |
<b>Saves to Shots ratio Outside Box</b> |
<p class="p3">82.86%</p> |
<p class="p2">3</p> |
<b>Goalkeeper Smother</b> |
<p class="p2">1</p> |
<p class="p2">31</p> |
<b>Catches</b> |
<p class="p2">18</p> |
<p class="p2">15</p> |
<b>Punches</b> |
<p class="p2">9</p> |
<p class="p2">3</p> |
<b>Drops</b> |
<p class="p2">7</p> |
<p class="p2">2</p> |
<b>Crosses not Claimed</b> |
<p class="p2">4</p> |
<p class="p3">93.88%</p> |
<b>Catch Success Rate</b> |
<p class="p3">79.41%</p> |
<p class="p2">3</p> |
<b>Clean Sheets</b> |
<p class="p2">3</p> |
<p class="p2">214</p> |
<b>GK - Pick up</b> |
<p class="p2">165</p> |
<p class="p2">0</p> |
<b>Error leading to Goal</b> |
<p class="p2">3</p> |
<p class="p2">0</p> |
<b>Error leading to Attempt</b> |
<p class="p2">2</p> |
<p class="p2">105</p> |
<b>Shots On Conceded</b> |
<p class="p2">104</p> |
<p class="p2">62</p> |
<b>Shots On Conceded Inside Box</b> |
<p class="p2">69</p> |
<p class="p2">43</p> |
<b>Shots On Conceded Outside Box</b> |
<p class="p2">35</p> |
<p class="p3">59.05%</p> |
<b>% Shots On Conceded Inside Box</b> |
<p class="p3">66.35%</p> |
<p class="p3">40.95%</p> |
<b>% Shots On Conceded Outside Box</b> |
<p class="p3">33.65%</p> |
<p class="p2">24</p> |
<b>Saves Parried Safe</b> |
<p class="p2">20</p> |
<p class="p2">7</p> |
<b>Saves Parried Danger</b> |
<p class="p2">15</p> |
<p class="p2">22</p> |
<b>Saves Caught</b> |
<p class="p2">8</p> |
<p class="p2">13</p> |
<b>Saves Collected</b> |
<p class="p2">15</p> |
<p class="p2">26</p> |
<b>Keeper Sweeper Successful</b> |
<p class="p2">32</p> |
<p class="p2">5</p> |
<b>Keeper Sweeper Unsuccessful</b> |
<p class="p2">6</p> |
<p class="p2">0</p> |
<b>Recoveries in Opp Half</b> |
<p class="p2">0</p> |
<p class="p2">0</p> |
<b>Goals Conceded from Fast Break</b> |
<p class="p2">0</p> |
<p class="p2">4</p> |
<b>Attempts Conceded from Fast Break</b> |
<p class="p2">6</p> |
<p class="p2">29</p> |
<b>Big Chance Faced</b> |
<p class="p2">35</p> |
<p class="p2">15</p> |
<b>Big Chance Goals Conceded</b> |
<p class="p2">22</p> |
<p class="p2">2</p> |
<b>Big Chance Saved</b> |
<p class="p2">5</p> |
<p class="p2">12</p> |
<b>Big Chance Missed</b> |
<p class="p2">8</p> |
<p class="p3">11.76%</p> |
<b>Big Chance Prevention %</b> |
<p class="p3">18.52%</p> |
