Round 1
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | RSL |
Nikolas Besagno* |
M | Generation adidas |
| 2 | CHV | Brad Guzan' | GK | South Carolina |
| 3 | CHI | Chad Barrett* | F | UCLA |
| 4 | SJ
(from FCD) |
Danny O'Rourke | M | Indiana |
| 5 | LA
(from SJ) |
Ugo Ihemelu | D | SMU |
| 6 | DAL |
Drew Moor* (from NY) |
M | Indiana |
| 7 | COL | Hunter Freeman* | D | Virginia |
| 8 | LA
(from CLB)` |
Troy Roberts | D | California |
| 9 |
NE |
Michael Parkhurst* | D | Wake Forest |
| 10 |
CHI (from LA) |
Jack Stewart | D | Notre Dame |
| 11 | KC | Scott Sealy | F | Wake Forest |
| 12 | NY/NJ
(from FCD) |
Tim Ward* | D | Saint Louis |
Round 2
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | RSL | Jamie Watson* | F | North Carolina |
| 14 | CHV | Christian Jimenez* | M | South Florida |
| 15 | LA
(from KC) |
Michael Enfield | M | UCLA |
| 16 | KC
(from COL) |
Ryan Pore* | F | Tulsa |
| 17 | SJ | Kevin Goldthwaite | D | Notre Dame |
| 18 |
CHI (from NY) |
Will John* | M | Saint Louis |
| 19 | DC
(from COL) |
Nick Van Sicklen | M | Wisconsin |
| 20 |
CLB (from COL) |
Marcus Storey | M | North Carolina |
| 21 | NE | James Riley | D | Wake Forest |
| 22 | RSL
(from LA) |
Jay Nolly | GK | Indiana |
| 23 |
CLB (from KC) |
Domenic Mediate | M | Maryland |
| 24 | KC
(from DC) |
Christopher Sawyer | GK | Notre Dame |
Round 3
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | NY/NJ
(from DC) |
Chris Corcoran | M | St. John's |
| 26 | CHV | Aaron Lopez | D | UCLA |
| 27 | DAL
(from CHI) |
Winston Marshall | D | Wright State |
| 28 | DAL | Chris Gomez | GK | Brown |
| 29 |
CHI (from FCD) |
Chris Rolfe | F | Dayton |
| 30 | SJ
(from NY) |
Victor Arbelaez |
M | UNLV |
| 31 | SJ
(from COL) |
Orlando Ramirez | F | Fresno Pacific |
| 32 | SJ
(from CLB) |
C.J. Klaas | D | Washington |
| 33 |
NE (from COL) |
Tony Lochhead | D | UC Santa Barbara |
| 34 | LA | Quavas Kirk* | F | Generation adidas |
| 35 |
CHI (from KC) |
Gonzalo Segares | D | Virginia Commonwealth |
| 36 |
CHI (from COL) |
Thabiso Khumalo | M | Coastal Carolina |
Round 4
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 37 | RSL | Luke Kreamalmeyer | M | Bradley |
| 38 | CHV | Esteban Arias | D | Connecticut |
| 39 |
CHI |
Karim Deltz | F | Birmingham Southern |
| 40 | DAL | Julian Nash | F | Creighton |
| 41 | SJ
(from COL) |
Antouman Jallow | F | Wisconsin-Milwaukee |
| 42 | SJ
(from NY) |
James Twellman | D | Stanford |
| 43 | COL | Guy Melamed | D | Boston College |
| 44 |
CLB |
Knox Cameron | F | Michigan |
| 45 | COL
(from NE) |
Amir Lowery | M | Wake Forest |
| 46 | LA | Mubarike Chisoni | M | Coastal Carolina |
| 47 | KC | John Minagawa-Webster | M | Michigan State |
| 48 | DC
(from SJ) |
Tim Merritt | D | North Carolina |
* Generation adidas