Round 1
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CHV | Drew Helm | F | Florida Atlantic |
| 2 | RSL | Jeff Rowland | F | New Mexico |
| 3 | CLB | Andy Gruenebaum | GK | Kentucky |
| 4 | KC | Anthony Noriega | M | George Mason |
| 5 | NY | Joe Vide | M | Virginia |
| 6 | DAL | Christopher Joyce | F | Franklin-Pierce |
| 7 | HOU - (from DC) | Mpho Moloi | M | Connecticut |
| 8 | DAL - (from HOU) | Miguel Guante | D | University of Portland |
| 9 | COL | Jordan Harvey | D | UCLA |
| 10 | CHI | Floyd Franks | M | UNC-Charlotte |
| 11 | NE | Danny Wynn | M | Saint Louis University |
| 12 | LA | Trevor McEachron | D | Old Dominion |
Round 2
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | CHV | Darren Spicer | D | Princeton |
| 14 | RSL | Willis Forko | D | Connecticut |
| 15 | CLB | David Chun | M | SMU |
| 16 | KC | Ryan McMahen | M/F | Michigan State |
| 17 | NY | Pete Dzubay | GK | Michigan |
| 18 | DAL | Brad Napper | M/F | Northwestern |
| 19 | DC | Andy Metcalf | F | Memphis |
| 20 | HOU | Hector Guzman | F | UC-Santa Clara |
| 21 | COL | Liam Girrard | D | Denver |
| 22 | CHI | Dasan Robinson | D | Dayton |
| 23 | NE | John Queeley | D | NC State |
| 24 | LA | Daniel Paladini | M | Cal State-Northridge |
Round 3
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | CHV | Lawson Vaughn | M | Tulsa |
| 26 | RSL | Chase Harrison | GK | Virginia Tech |
| 27 | CLB | Ivan Becerra | F | UCSB |
| 28 | KC | Corey Farabi | M | Drake |
| 29 | NY | Brian Cvilikas | F | Old Dominion |
| 30 | DAL | Sean Babcock | M | University of Portland |
| 31 | NY - (from DC) | Brian Devlin | M | Penn State |
| 32 | HOU | Tony Donatelli | M | Temple |
| 33 | COL | Keith Cauldwell | M | Brown |
| 34 | CHI | Ezra Prendergast | D | Syracuse |
| 35 | NE | Adam Williamson | M | Lehigh |
| 36 | LA | Armando Melendez | M/F | Loyola Marymount |
Round 4
| Pick | Club | Player's Name | Position | School/Previous Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 37 | HOU - (from CHV) | Josh Fender | F | West Texas A&M |
| 38 | COL | Daniel Wasson | M/D | Tulsa |
| 39 | DAL - (from NY) | Peter Louis | F | Coastal Carolina |
| 40 | KC | Chris Hamberger | M | Drake |
| 41 | RSL - (from NY) | Chris Lancos | D | Maryland |
| 42 | CHI - (from COL) | Idris Ughiovhe | D | Howard |
| 43 | DC | Devon McTavish | D | West Virginia |
| 44 | HOU | PASS | ||
| 45 | KC - (from COL) | Luke Enna | M | Tampa |
| 46 | CHI | Richard Mupfudze | F | Western Kentucky |
| 47 | NE | Matt Wieland | D | Creighton |
| 48 | LA | Matt Couch | F | San Diego State |