Welcome to the latest installment of MLSsoccer.com's "This or That?" It's as simple as it gets: You choose one of two things. Sometimes you might want a third option or a "both" option, but that's not the point. The point is to present either/or question and find out where people's opinions lie.
They are the two biggest names to grace the fields of MLS. Between them, they have eight EPL titles, three La Liga titles, two UEFA Champions League titles, one World Cup, one Euro Championship, and one MLS Supporters' Shield.
And on Saturday, LA Galaxy superstar David Beckham will face New York Red Bulls superstar for the first time since in MLS.
So which one would you rather have on your club?
Make sure to use the hashtag #LAvNY on Twitter when discussing the LA Galaxy-New York Red Bulls.