Why 5 Defenders works in MLS Fantasy Soccer: Manager

These days, 5-3-2 is usually seen as a sign of respect when facing an opponent far superior in strength (e.g., anyone vs. Barcelona).

But to win in Fantasy Soccer: Manager, perhaps it's best to think that you are playing Messi & Co. each week. The FS:M Dream Team has lined up with five defenders four out of five weeks thus far. Ironically, this formation is producing more points for teams than the 4-3-3 and 3-4-3. I myself have been lined up mostly in a 3-4-3 thinking that midfielders and forwards would get me the most points. Fail.

Player HAWAIIFAN13 proved the benefits of the 5-3-2. In Week 5, he rode the formation to 106 points, the second highest score recorded by a team this year.

So what does this mean for the rest of the 2012? Do the stats suggest taking a completely different approach and start dumping midfielders (and even forwards) for defenders? You be the judge.

Players averaging 5.0 points or more per game (by position)

Defenders – 27
Goalkeepers – 12
Midfielders – 10
Forwards – 8

The numbers above should make your decision a little easier. At this point in the season, there is more security in starting defenders than there is at any other position. Honestly, it’s not even close. Forwards and midfielders can be a huge investment, and so far, most of them aren’t living up to the asking price.

Need help with your squad? Tweet your MLS Fantasy Soccer questions to @Ben_Jata


Portland Timbers gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for Timbers hats, hoodies, jerseys, shirts and more.


Real Salt Lake gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for RSL hats, hoodies, jerseys, shirts and more.


San Jose Earthquakes gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for Earthquakes jerseys, shirts, hats, hoodies and more.


Philadelphia Union gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for Union hats, hoodies, jerseys, shirts and more.


New England Revolution gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for Revolution hats, hoodies, jerseys, shirts and more.


D.C. United gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for D.C. United hats, hoodies, jerseys, shirts and more.


Houston Dynamo gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for Dynamo hats, hoodies, jerseys, shirts and more.


LA Galaxy gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for LA Galaxy hats, hoodies, jerseys, shirts and more.


FC Dallas gear | mlsstore.com

Shop mlsstore.com for FC Dallas jerseys, shirts, hats, hoodies and more.