Makubuya joined three other Academy teammates when he signed for the First Team on March 17, 2011. Makubuya joined the Toronto FC Academy in 2009 after leaving the North Mississauga Soccer club. Prior to his time with North Mississauga he played with the St. Catharines Concord Soccer Club.
2011: Appeared in one match, logging 45 minutes. His loan appearance came in the season opener on March 19 against the Vancouver Whitecaps as a second half substitute.